Why Aren’t Mice Responding To My Mouse Traps?

Sure, mouse traps seem like a quick and easy fix to a mouse problem and while they might work for a bit, oftentimes mice stop taking the bait. If you’ve found yourself in this type of predicament and are wondering why the mice in your home aren’t responding to the mouse traps you’ve set up as they did at first, we have a couple of thoughts on the matter.

Mice Responding To My Mouse Traps

You’re reusing old traps

The issue with reusing old mouse traps is two-fold. First, there’s probably old bait dried or caked on it and just as you wouldn’t eat off a dirty plate, they’re not going to eat off a dirty trap. Secondly, they’re keen sense of smell warns these rodents away from old mouse traps. More on that below.

You’re handling mouse traps with bare hands 

You might think that the smell of peanut butter on the trap would override your smell but mice will pick up your scent no matter how strong the bait is. As you can probably imagine, they aren’t going to even try to take the bait if they’re picking up human scent. That’s why it’s best to use gloves when loading bait. 

The smell of dead mice repels them 

Smelling dead mice on a trap will also deter mice from coming too close to your mouse trap. Once they realize it, they’ll start avoiding areas where they know you’ve rigged trap(s) up. Removing dead mice as soon as they’ve been caught and setting a new trap is one way to avoid this particular problem. 

You’re putting too much bait on the mouse trap

Too much bait on mouse traps will not help you win the battle against mice. In fact, it will become a stumbling block. You see, too much bait allows mice to feed without activating the trap AND you’re providing them with the sustenance they need to survive. To be effective, a mouse trap only needs a small amount of bait and it must be placed in the right spot to trigger. 

Are mouse traps an effective solution then?

Mouse traps can be an effective tool in the fight against mice but there’s more to it than you might think. You must consider how quickly a mouse population grows when determining the number of traps you need. As we’ve touched on in previous blog posts about mice, a single adult female mouse can give birth to 12 babies per litter and is capable of producing multiple litters each year. If you’re only setting out a few traps, you’re probably not keeping pace. 

No matter how many traps you set, they won’t stop the problem if you don’t fix how they’re getting inside. In order to eliminate mouse activity in your home, you cannot ignore how they’re getting in. If you don’t seal off every and we mean every hole that they can fit through, it doesn’t really matter what you’re doing on the inside. 

Is there a better way to get rid of mice?

While mouse traps have merit, the best way to get rid of mice is to contact a licensed pest control company. Here at Arrow Pest Control, we offer effective rodent control services in Essex Fells, Roseland, Caldwell as well as throughout Essex County and several other New Jersey counties. When you contact us for help exterminating your mouse (or rat) problem, we will: 

  • Inspect your home to determine if rodents are present and identify any conditions that attract these pests to your home
  • Target existing rodent populations using mechanical rodent control devices
  • Seal up holes that mice use to enter
  • Monitor your property for rodents by setting up exterior bait stations as well as interior ones if necessary
  • Let you know if we have any recommendations on how to make your property less attractive to rodents 

For homeowners who find mice are a year-round struggle in their homes and garages, Arrow Pest Control offers home pest control services that not only take care of insects but also rodents who wander in no matter the season. Compare residential plans and pricing below or give us a call to discuss your pest problem!

HOME PROTECTION
Starting at
$37/mo
 
What's included:
  • Year-Round Pest Protection
  • 3 Seasonal Services
  • Covers 30+ Pests
  • The Arrow Promise
  • Carpenter Ant Control
    (Includes Carpenter Ants, Pharaoh Ants & Acrobat Ants)
  • Carpenter Bee Coverage
  • Termite Monitoring Advantage
  • Termite Control
  • Stink Bugs
  • Ticks & Mosquitoes
  • White Glove Service
HOME PROTECTION PLUS
Starting at
$52/mo
 
What's included:
  • Year-Round Pest Protection
  • 3 Seasonal Services
  • Covers 30+ Pests
  • The Arrow Promise
  • Carpenter Ant Control
    (Includes Carpenter Ants, Pharaoh Ants & Acrobat Ants)
  • Carpenter Bee Coverage
  • Termite Monitoring Advantage
  • Termite Control
  • Stink Bugs
  • Ticks & Mosquitoes
  • White Glove Service
ARROW PREMIER
Starting at
$67/mo
 
What's included:
  • Year-Round Pest Protection
  • 4 Seasonal Services
  • Covers 30+ Pests
  • The Arrow Promise
  • Carpenter Ant Control
    (Includes Carpenter Ants, Pharaoh Ants & Acrobat Ants)
  • Carpenter Bee Coverage
  • Annual Wood Destroying Organism Report
  • Termite Control
  • Stink Bugs
  • Ticks & Mosquitoes
  • White Glove Service
ARROW ONE
Starting at
$99/mo
 
What's included:
  • Year-Round Pest Protection
  • 8 Seasonal Services
  • Covers 30+ Pests
  • The Arrow Promise
  • Carpenter Ant Control
    (Includes Carpenter Ants, Pharaoh Ants & Acrobat Ants)
  • Carpenter Bee Coverage
  • Annual Wood Destroying Organism Report
  • Termite Control
  • Stink Bugs
  • Ticks & Mosquitoes
  • White Glove Service
**An initial set up fee will apply
Jeff K

Testimonials

‟I have a service plan with Arrow and use them quite often. Never disappointed, always friendly and knowledgeable and come right out and address the matter. I wouldn’t hesitate to recommend them at all.”

Jeffrey K.
Marlboro, NJ
Jared L.

Testimonials

‟We have a quarterly service plan with Arrow. They are not only focused on addressing issues they put preventative measures in place to prevent issues from happening, like looking for and sealing the places where bugs can get into the home. The team are professional, friendly, thorough and provide details about every step of their process. We have had several different technicians over the last 2 years and each follows the same process and guidelines. Definitely recommend for treatment and prevention.”

Jared L.
Manalapan, NJ
Jeff K.

Testimonials

‟My family has used Arrow since the early 80's. In our new home we use them as well. Jason came yesterday and did a great job. Thanks again for your great service to our community!”

Jeff K.
Farmingdale, NJ
John C.

Testimonials

‟Best customer service and the owner is the most honest business man. He will tell you the truth and not scam you like the rest of the big named pest control companies. Highly recommend Arrow has my business for life.”

John C.
Bloomfield, NJ
Joe F.

Testimonials

‟I used Arrow Pest Control for the first time today and I was totally satisfied, I reached out to them on Sunday and spoke to Beatrice and she set me up an appointment for Monday morn for an estimate and Monday afternoon the technician came and serviced my house.....I wish I could have gave them 10 stars, very helpful, right to the point, very professional, on time and no games.....I highly recommend arrow pest control in Morganville.......thank you J.F.”

Joe F.
Matawan, NJ
Lauren C.

Testimonials

‟With Covid hitting everyone, the exterminator that helped us was respectful of the safety with a mask, boots and gloves. He was very informative and explained everything as he did it.”

Lauren C.
Old Bridge, NJ
Renee R

Testimonials

‟We’ve been using Arrow for the last 4 years. We have a monthly plan, so they come and service the interior and exterior regularly. We can also call them anytime for anything we see...wasp, wasp nests, rodents, ants, whatever...our coverage literally includes the mailbox at the curb all the way to the furthest point of our backyard fence and everything in between. All the technicians we’ve had, including Jason, were friendly and knowledgeable. But, Jason, goes above and beyond with his service and willingness to do more for his customers. Highly recommend Arrow Pest Control!”

Renee R.
Short Hills, NJ
Lisa M.

Testimonials

‟Tom is amazing! Arrow is the best company! Love their services. They truly care about their clients. ”

Lisa M.
Port Monmouth, NJ
Elena C.

Testimonials

‟Today was my first appointment with Arrow and Jason made everything seamless and efficient. Not only was he knowledgeable, he took his time explaining everything to me which proved he cared. I’m happy to have found Arrow and will continue to request Jason for my services! Thank you!”

Elena C.
Manalapan, NJ
Deb C.

Testimonials

‟All the professional qualities a business such as Arrow Pest Control would expect a service technician to exhibit, Brian, effortlessly presented. From my standpoint, he offered GOLD STAR ”

Deb C.
Jackson, NJ
Mary F.

Testimonials

‟Recommended to us by neighbors, Arrow arrived promptly to treat our new to us home. The house is built on a slab which small ants love to nest in.

Their program is such that they return til the problem is solved. Today was their third visit. Steve was very thorough, professional and had a great sense of humor. I am hoping not to see him again this season! I would recommend based on our current relationship.
Like”

Mary F.
Lakewood, NJ
Kathleen F.

Testimonials

‟I’m so happy we went with Arrow! We had been using another pest control company and still had a lot of spiders and crickets!! We switched to Arrow and after the first use with them, all the bugs were gone. They do a great job, very thorough, professional, friendly and very knowledgeable. I highly recommend using their services if you have any bug issues!”

Kathleen F.
Toms River, NJ
Deborah S.

Testimonials

‟We were very pleased with how easy it was to schedule a first appointment with Rob and how reassuring and thorough his inspection was. A few hours later Josh arrived for the first treatment and was professional and took the time to answer all our questions. We didn’t hesitate to sign-up for Home Protection Program after seeing the quality and level of service we will receive.”

Deborah S.
Monroe, NJ
Dr. Lisa L.

Testimonials

‟Arrow and Brian with Arrow were amazing! He came same day when we heard scary noises in our attic. He found mice and a loose wire and even took a photo so we could see. He worked hard to crawl into a tiny space and we are so appreciate!! We can sleep tonight thanks to him.”

Dr. Lisa L.
East Brunswick, NJ
Thomas N.

Testimonials

‟Extremely professional and always on time. I was having an issue with mice and decided to call Arrow. They were able to get here next day and have an inspection. I set up with one of their monthly contracts and they were out to my home once a week continuously monitoring the situation until it was fully taken care of. I truly couldn’t recommend them more.”

Thomas N.
Monroe, NJ
Arrow Pest Control received an average rating of 5.0 out of 5 stars from 1380 reviews. 5.0 Read Google Reviews

Request Your FREE Estimate

Schedule Your No Obligation Inspection Today

Arrow Pest Control Blog

Read the latest articles & news

September 25, 2023

Fall Tick Treatments In New Jersey Are A Must

We know what you’re thinking, it’s getting colder out and there’s no need…
Read More
September 13, 2023

Types Of Ticks In New Jersey

There’s an arachnid on the move in backyards across New Jersey. We're not…
Read More
September 1, 2023

Five Home Maintenance Tips To Repel Pests This Fall

It won’t be long before we wake up to chilly mornings and notice leaves…
Read More
August 21, 2023

Where Do Yellow Jackets Build Their Nests & Other Yellow Jacket FAQs

If you’ve lived in New Jersey for any length of time, there’s a good chance…
Read More
August 4, 2023

Lone Star Tick Bites To Blame For Meat Allergy

Late last month, the CDC issued a press release regarding the emergence of a…
Read More
July 25, 2023

Do Bed Bugs Get Worse In The Summer?

The summer travel season is in full swing and as anticipated, bed bugs are…
Read More
July 3, 2023

Spotted Lanternfly Problems in Monmouth County & Throughout New Jersey

Holmdel, Morganville, and communities in Monmouth County as well as elsewhere in…
Read More
June 12, 2023

How To Keep Clover Mites Out Of Your NJ Home

Clover mites are tiny pests that can become a nuisance for New Jersey homeowners…
Read More
June 3, 2023

How To Spot Potential Pest Problems When Buying A Home

According to real estate experts, June is a great time to buy a new home in New…
Read More
May 18, 2023

Why Am I Suddenly Seeing Flying Ants In My Home?

The sudden appearance of flying ants inside your home can be quite unsettling…
Read More